U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Federal Health Care Law

Details

Publish Date:
June 25, 2015
Author(s):
    ,
Source:
San Francisco Chronicle
Related Person(s):
Related Organization(s):

Summary

Professors Hank Greely and David Studdert weigh in on the Supreme Court’s decision upholding the federal health care law and the message the decision sends. 

Three years after narrowly surviving a legal challenge, President Obama’s signature health insurance law faced another threat to its survival in much of the nation Thursday before a U.S. Supreme Court led by conservative Republican appointees. The health law prevailed, with something to spare, an apparent signal of its future endurance.

The 6-3 ruling upheld tax-credit subsidies that have helped to make health coverage affordable for most of the more than 15 million Americans newly covered by the law. The case hinged on a brief passage in the 800-page statute enacted in 2010 that said the government must provide subsidies to “an exchange covered by the state.”

The ruling is “a decisive statement from the majority that this is an important social reform,” said David Studdert, a professor of law and medicine at Stanford University. “Whether you agree with it or not, Congress intended it to work in a certain way.”

Henry Greely, who teaches health care law at Stanford, agreed Thursday’s ruling was a clear signal from the court. “I think it means the Supreme Court challenges (to the law) have just about run out of gas,” he said.

Read More