The Open Science Movement and Its Implications for Expert Testimony

Abstract

The American academy – and arguably the very idea of meritocracy – is experiencing a fierce backlash. In this essay I examine expert testimony at trial, a domain where expertise has been viewed with cynicism and distrust for decades, and ask whether the recent Open Science movement offers new ways of improving the credibility of expert testimony at trial, and helping fact-Finders to make appropriate use of that input. This seemingly straightforward question does not have a straightforward answer, for two reasons. First, the Open Science movement reFlects the norms of an inquisitorial model of fact-Finding that is in tension with the norms of the adversarial legal model. Second, some Open Science reforms seek to correct a different motivational problem than the ones that makes expert testimony controversial. I instead explore and endorse two approaches better suited to the problem, blinded data analysis and calibration weighting. Each mitigates bias while respecting adversarialism and expert autonomy.

Details

Author(s):
Publish Date:
May, 2026
Publisher:
DePaul University Law Review
Format:
Journal Article Page(s) 537-568
Citation(s):
  • Robert J. MacCoun, The Open Science Movement and Its Implications for Expert Testimony. Clifford Symposium on Social Science and Civil Justice, 75 DePaul L. Rev. 537 (2026).    

Other Publications By